Serving Shorewood, WI Since 1971 Call Us: (414) 961-0999 | 4409 N Oakland Ave, Shorewood, WI 53211
What We Buy
U.S. and Foreign Coins
$
From well-worn pocket change to rare numismatic finds, Shorewood Coin Shop pays top dollar for U.S. and foreign coins of every era — and our experts can tell the difference between the two in minutes.
Domestic or Foreign, Common or Rare — We Want to See It
Whether you've inherited a coffee can of old coins, found a jar of foreign currency from a family trip abroad, or you're a serious collector looking to sell part of your collection, our knowledgeable staff will evaluate your coins honestly and pay you a fair, competitive price. No collection is too large or too small.
U.S. Coins
Wheat pennies, silver dimes and quarters, Morgan and Peace dollars, Indian Head cents, Mercury dimes, gold coins, commemoratives, error coins, and modern proof and mint sets. If it's American currency, we know its history and its value.
Foreign Coins
World coins, ancient and medieval currency, European and Latin American issues, foreign gold and silver coinage, and collections brought back from travel or passed down through generations.
Just Some of What We Look For
• Silver and Gold U.S. Coins
• Ancient and World Coins
• Morgan & Peace Silver Dollars
• Indian Head & Wheat Pennies
• Proof & Mint Sets
• Error and Misprint Coins
• Commemorative Coin Issues
• Foreign Gold and Silver Coins
• Inherited or Estate Collections
• Bulk and Accumulation Lots
What to Expect
1
Bring It In
Visit our Shorewood shop with your coins, or call to arrange a consultation. No appointment necessary for most collections.
2
We Evaluate
Our numismatic experts examine your coins for date, mint mark, condition, rarity, and metal content — U.S. or foreign, ancient or modern.
3
You Get Paid
We give you a fair, upfront offer based on current market value. No pressure, no obligation — and cash in hand if you accept.
Not sure what you have? Bring it in anyway. Some of our best finds started as "just a jar of old coins."
